Economist: Palm Black Campaign Just Business Competition

JAKARTA – The black campaign against the palm oil is believed to have been merely aimed to win business competition. Global producers of other vegetable oils could not compete with the palm oil which is very efficient and cheap in price, so that they turned to non-tariff barriers, such as environmental issues.

”As the palm oil is very competitive at the global market, its competitors, like producers of soybean, rapeseed and sunflower, could not out-compete the palm oil by relying only on price strategy,” Tungkot Sipayung, Economist and Executive Director of the Palm Oil Agribusiness Strategic Policy Institute (PASPI) said during a public discussion in Jakarta recently.

He believed that if the competition is only in terms of price, other vegetable oils will certainly lose the competition. “That’s why the producers of other vegetable oils turned to the strategy of non-tariff barriers. They launched the black campaigns by accusing the palm oil as the cause of deforestation, human rights violation, and other vilifying statements against the palm oil at the global market,” he said.

Tungkot Sipayung pointed out that there are 17 kinds of oil crops that can be used to produce the vegetable oils at the global market. But only four of them are the main sources, namely oil palm, soybean, rapeseed and sunflower. The four vegetable oils produce around 90% of the global vegetable oils, with the palm oil contributing the biggest supply among the four.

Unlike other oil crops, the oil palm trees are not seasonal plants but perennial ones. Being perennial, the oil palm trees are more resilient to climate change and are productive during rainy and dry seasons. The oil palm productivity is also 10 times higher than those of other oil crops.

With such advantages, the palm oil supply can be made stable in big volumes and preferred by the vegetable oil importing countries which need a certainty of supply along the year.

In addition to that, the palm oil is the most versatile among the other vegetable oils as it has a wide range of uses, including as raw materials to feed various industries from foods, health, cosmetic, personal care and energy (biofuel). “That’s why the selling price of crude palm oil (CPO) and its derivative products are very economic and competitive at the market compared to other vegetable oils. The palm oil is the king of vegetable oils at the global market,” he asserted.

Regarding the deforestation accusation against the palm oil, Tungkot said that a number of researches have proven that without palm oil, the global deforestation, soil and water pollutions will be much higher. “Biodiversity loss will be also higher if the world decides not to use palm oil. So, those who launch the anti-palm oil campaigns are actually pushing up bigger deforestation in the world,” he said.

He stated that if oil palm cultivation is halted then other oil crops will be planted as a replacement. The other oil crops, such as soybean, rapeseed and sunflower will be forced to produce like the oil palm trees. The land sites for such cultivation will not be enough, even if all areas of Amazon tropical forests are used.

From the perspective of public welfare around the oil palm plantations, he cited many studies that have proven that the existence of oil palm plantations have generated local economic growth, improved the economic and social life of local people, and improved the ecological condition of regions. “Generally, the oil palm plantations were developed in remote and less developed areas, and marginal land sites. Now, we’ve seen that the oil palm plantations have turned the remote and least developed areas into new growth centers, in Aceh, North Sumatera, Riau, Kalimantan, and Papua. These are the contributions of the palm oil industries to our regional and national economy,” he concluded. (*)

Source: neraca.co.id