< All Topics
Print

What Is Vegetable Shortening? Function, Production, and Quality Standards

Key Points: Vegetable Shortening
  • Shortening is a fat that is solid or semi-solid at room temperature and is used to make food crisp, tender, or easy to shape—not merely ‘solid cooking oil’.[1][2]
  • Palm oil is well suited as a shortening raw material because it is naturally semi-solid, oxidation-stable, and tends to form fine β′ crystals.[3][4]
  • Palm-based shortening can be produced without partial hydrogenation, so its trans-fat potential is low—provided the formulation and process are correct.[4][5]
  • In Indonesia, shortening quality is covered by SNI 3718:2018 Lemak Reroti (Shortening), and trans fat is addressed within the sugar-salt-fat (GGL) control framework.[6][7]

The word ‘shortening’ comes from ‘short’, meaning to make dough more open and tender. Modern shortening is usually made from vegetable oils—and palm oil is one of the main raw materials because of its natural semi-solid character. Accurate understanding of shortening matters for both food businesses and consumers, especially because trans fat and product quality are often discussed generally without distinguishing the type of fat and the process used.

What is shortening?

Shortening is a fat that is solid or semi-solid at room temperature and is used to give food a crisp, tender, or easy-to-shape texture. The term comes from ‘short’ because fat coats flour particles so that gluten bonds become shorter and the dough is easier to cut or chew.[1][2]

Technically, shortening is not limited to vegetable oil: butter, lard, and margarine also count as shortening because they are all solid at room temperature. In everyday use, however, ‘shortening’ usually refers to a vegetable-oil-based product processed to be semi-solid.[1][2]

Differences between shortening and other fats and oils
Type Character at room temperature Main role
Liquid oil (e.g. palm olein) Liquid Frying medium; adds moisture
Vegetable shortening Solid/semi-solid, smooth Makes dough open, aerated, or crisp
Margarine Solid, contains water Flavour, aroma, and texture in bread and cakes
Butter Solid, dairy-derived Characteristic flavour and aroma; high water content
Animal fat (lard) Solid Crisp texture in traditional pastry
The boundaries between these categories are not always sharp: some commercial products are blends or are positioned for specific applications.

Function of shortening in food

The main function of shortening is to coat flour particles so that gluten does not form too strong a network. As a result the texture becomes softer (in cakes) or crispier (in biscuits and pastry). In creaming, fat also traps air bubbles that determine cake volume and softness.[1][9]

Besides texture, shortening gives plasticity to dough (easy to shape without cracking), lubricates surfaces, and influences flavour and mouthfeel. In fried products, fat acts as a heat-transfer medium while also determining crispness and shelf life.[1][3]

Why is palm oil suitable for shortening?

Palm oil is naturally semi-solid because it is rich in palmitic acid (about 39–47% of total fatty acids) and contains moderate amounts of oleic and linoleic acid. This means it does not always require partial hydrogenation to reach a solid consistency.[3][12]

Palm oil has relatively good oxidative stability because its linolenic acid content is very low, while natural tocopherols range from 380–890 ppm and act as antioxidants. This combination makes palm-based shortening durable for frying and storage.[3]

In terms of crystals, palm oil tends to form fine, stable β′ polymorphs rather than large, sandy β crystals. β′ crystals are desirable for creaming, plasticity, and a smooth texture in bakery shortening.[4][9]

Shortening production process

Shortening is produced by blending fats or oils from vegetable, animal, or fish sources and then adjusting their physical properties. Common routes include blending, fractionation, hydrogenation (full or partial), and interesterification.[3][4]

Fractionation separates palm oil into a liquid fraction (olein) and a solid fraction (stearin). Stearin can be used as a ‘hard stock’ to raise shortening hardness without hydrogenation. Interesterification rearranges fatty acids on the triglyceride so that solid-fat properties change without forming trans fatty acids.[4][13]

After blending, the liquid fat is rapidly cooled in a scraped-surface heat exchanger and agitated so that fine crystals form. Emulsifiers, antioxidants, or colour may be added according to the end product’s function.[3][4]

Process routes and their effect on shortening properties
Process route What changes Note
Fractionation Proportion of liquid and solid fractions Adjusts hardness without hydrogenation
Full hydrogenation Double bonds become saturated Does not form trans fat, but hardness rises
Partial hydrogenation Some double bonds saturate, some change configuration Can form trans fat; restricted/avoided
Interesterification Arrangement of fatty acids on the triglyceride Changes physical properties without trans fat
Blending Overall fatty-acid composition Most flexible and widely used

Physicochemical properties that determine performance

Shortening performance is determined by solid fat content (SFC) at various temperatures, melting point, and crystal form. SFC indicates how much fat is crystalline at a given temperature; this is what distinguishes cake shortening, pastry shortening, and frying shortening.[4][9]

β′ crystals give a smooth texture and good air-holding capacity, whereas β crystals tend to be large, sandy, and less suitable for creaming. Controlled cooling and agitation are needed so that the desired polymorph forms and remains stable.[9][4]

Other relevant quality parameters include free fatty acids, moisture, peroxide value, and trans-fat content. Specific limits apply according to the standard referenced, not to values from one product or one study.[6][9]

Shortening applications

Shortening is widely used in the bakery industry (cakes, biscuits, puff pastry, bread, cream, and icing), frying, and other foods that need a particular texture. All-purpose shortening is marketed for several applications, while specialty shortening is designed for specific functions such as creaming or lamination.[1][3]

Research in Indonesia has tested shortening based on red palm oil and sesame–palm oil blends. In those studies the quality measured included moisture, free fatty acids, peroxide value, melting point, and sensory properties—showing that non-palm raw materials can also be formulated into shortening with performance close to commercial products.[10][11]

Shortening applications and their functional requirements
Application Main functional requirement
Cakes Air-holding (creaming), smooth texture, correct SFC at room temperature
Biscuits and pastry Plasticity, ease of lamination, crisp texture
Bread and laminated dough Dough flexibility and stability during fermentation
Cream and icing Smooth, white, stable texture
Frying Oxidative stability, product shelf life, crispness

Quality standard: SNI 3718:2018

In Indonesia, shortening is covered by SNI 3718:2018 Lemak Reroti (shortening), established by the National Standardization Agency in October 2018. The standard covers processed fat or vegetable-oil products in liquid, semi-solid, or solid form, with or without added animal fat, milk fat, and permitted food additives.[6]

One quality requirement cited in implementation studies is a maximum free fatty acid level of 0.3%. This limit should be understood as a product requirement, not as the typical value of all shortening on the market; product quality verification is still carried out by testing against the referenced standard.[6][11]

Application of this SNI is also linked to the conformity-assessment scheme published by BSN and to wider food and labelling regulations. Because standards may be revised, businesses should refer to the latest edition and status.[6]

Trans fat, reformulation, and health issues

Trans fat is formed mainly when liquid oil undergoes partial hydrogenation. WHO states that industrially produced trans fat has no health benefit and should be eliminated from the food supply. WHO recommends a limit of less than 2 grams of trans fat per 100 grams of total fat, or a ban on partially hydrogenated oils (PHO).[5]

Good news: palm-based shortening can be formulated without partial hydrogenation—for example by fractionation, blending, or interesterification—so its trans-fat potential is low. Some studies have even produced trans-fat-free shortening from palm olein blends.[4][13]

In Indonesia, WHO and the Ministry of Health push for trans-fat elimination; a WHO survey of 130 food products found almost 10% of samples above the WHO recommendation, with the highest concentration in a margarine–butter mixture. The sugar-salt-fat (GGL) control framework in PP 28/2024 provides the basis for follow-up regulation on content limits and labelling.[7][8]

What consumers and industry should note

Consumers should read the ingredient list and nutrition information, not just the product name. The term ‘vegetable shortening’ does not automatically mean trans-fat free; what determines it is the process and fat composition.[1][5]

For industry, the choice of process route (fractionation vs partial hydrogenation vs interesterification) directly affects quality, cost, and product claims. Reformulation should be followed by quality testing and conformity verification.[4][6]

Finally, product information should separate technical facts (fat properties, performance, quality) from marketing claims. Shortening is not automatically ‘bad fat’, but neither is it an ingredient to be consumed without considering the overall dietary pattern.[1][5]

Conclusion

Shortening is a solid/semi-solid fat that functions to give food a crisp, tender, and plastic texture. Palm oil is an important raw material because it is naturally semi-solid, oxidation-stable, and tends to form fine β′ crystals.

With the right formulation and process—especially avoiding partial hydrogenation—palm-based shortening can be produced with low trans-fat potential and quality that meets SNI 3718:2018. Accurate understanding helps industry innovate and helps consumers read product claims critically.

References

  1. Institute of Food Science and Technology. Fats and oils: shortening. Accessed 2026. IFST.
  2. Encyclopaedia Britannica. Shortening. Britannica.
  3. Idris, N. A. Shortenings Based on Palm Oil Products. Palm Oil Technology Bulletin, Malaysian Palm Oil Board (MPOB). MPOB.
  4. List, G. R., & Marangoni, A. G. Trans Fat Replacements in Foods. American Oil Chemists’ Society (AOCS). AOCS.
  5. World Health Organization. (2024). Trans fat (Fact sheet, 24 January 2024). WHO.
  6. Badan Standardisasi Nasional. (2018). SNI 3718:2018 Lemak reroti (shortening). BSN.
  7. Pemerintah Republik Indonesia. (2024). Peraturan Pemerintah Nomor 28 Tahun 2024 tentang Peraturan Pelaksanaan Undang-Undang Nomor 17 Tahun 2023 tentang Kesehatan. BPK.
  8. World Health Organization Indonesia & Kementerian Kesehatan. (2024). WHO, Ministry of Health call to eliminate trans fat for healthier, more productive Indonesia (6 May 2024). WHO Indonesia.
  9. Research team. Lipid shortenings: a review. TAMU Food Protein Research & Development Center. TAMU.
  10. Pangemanan, R. et al. Pembuatan Margarin dan Baking Shortening Berbasis Minyak Sawit Merah dan Aplikasinya dalam Produk Bakery. agriTECH, 43(1). UGM Journal.
  11. Nurcahyani, A. et al. Pembuatan Shortening dari Minyak Wijen dan Minyak Sawit. Jurnal Sains dan Ilmu Terapan (JSIT). Politeknik Kampar.
  12. Research team. Balancing functional and health benefits of food products formulated with palm oil as oil sources (2022). PMC.
  13. Research team. Formulasi campuran olein minyak sawit untuk memproduksi shortening bebas lemak trans. JTHP, Universitas Lampung. Unila.
Table of Contents